The Best Seafood Restaurants in the Outer Banks

We are like moths to flames when it comes to having seafood near the seashore. It only made sense to try to find the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks when we visited.

There are so many restaurants in the Outer Banks we can’t possibly eat at them all. No one can. But these are the recommendations for the best seafood from the places we visited on our trip.

We also want to note that we found it more commonplace for menus to have fried seafood, which we didn’t want 99.5% of the time. If you like to err on the healthier side of seafood options, you’ll be pleased to know you won’t find us writing about fried dishes for the seafood restaurants below, with the exception of one towards the end.

We are sharing where we went, what we ordered and what we thought of these seafood restaurants, including stops in Nags Head, Manteo and Wanchese (both on Roanoke Island), Buxton and Hatteras.

Blue Water Grill & Raw Bar, in Manteo

This was THE PLACE to get raw oysters in the Outer Banks. We were baffled to discover it was so hard to find raw oysters anywhere in OBX. We still don’t quite understand why that’s so. Most places we went to had fried oyster on the menu. (Our waitress concurred it’s an oddity of the Outer Banks and she doesn’t understand it either.)

But we were so grateful for the Blue Water Grill & Raw Bar.

We had perfect seats inside, overlooking the marina below. It was a great indoor activity on a rainy day in the Outer Banks.

Trees and a restaurant behind it. A sign out front reads, "Blue Water Grill & Raw Bar" in the Outer Banks.

Raw Bar Selection of Oysters

We loved that visiting during October’s shoulder season meant they had an oyster Happy Hour for $1 oysters. (They have oysters even if it’s peak season, they just don’t have special happy hour pricing for them.)

You choose one condiment option from their menu per six oysters. We chose classics, a mignonette and cocktail sauce. Call us purists.

We tried to branch out by tasting a lemon horseradish sauce. But it tasted too much like we were putting salad dressing on the mollusks so we reverted back to our favorite firsts.

We also indulged in two Oyster Shooters. They are alcoholic shots with an oyster in the bottom of each one, vodka, and cocktail sauce if you’ve never tried them. The restaurant or bar you order it from usually puts their own spin on it, whether adding spices, like sea salt or hot sauce, or – in the case of Blue Water Grill – a refreshing pureed cucumber mixture.

We’re pretty nostalgic about oyster shooters and order them whenever we see them on a menu. We had them on our second date in Raleigh back in 2015, at 42nd Street Oyster Bar, and it was Dan’s first time tasting them. He doesn’t love them like I do (he likes them) but he’s always game to have one.

Crab Cake Dinner

Dinner was delicious. The crab cakes were pure lump crab. It didn’t seem like they had any filler so I’m not sure how they stuck together! They were served with a refreshing corn and tomato salsa and on top of yummy grits. Two thumbs up.

two lump crab cakes on top of cheesy grits with a corn salsa at Blue Water Grill in Manteo, NC.
Lump crab cakes on top of cheesy grits at one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks.

Pop’s Raw Bar, in Buxton

We discovered an absolute favorite spot to get seafood on this trip in the Outer Banks: Pop’s Raw Bar. It was perfection.

We sat at a picnic table on the outside deck and enjoyed sunshine and the view across NC-12 (the main road in OBX) to the water.

The front of a blue and white building, one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks, that says "Pop's" on the side.

It’s a no fuss, no frills kind of bar that serves seafood in a variety of ways. We’re not really sure why “raw” is in the name because everything on the menu is either fried or steamed. But we loved it just the same.

RELATED:  The Best Thing(s) I Ever Ate: Japan + Portugal

We ordered steamed clams that were served with a side of melted butter and cocktail sauce to dip them in. They were so good we ordered shrimp after that, wanting to try more on their menu and fill our bellies.

They serve local NC shrimp at what quickly became one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks in our eyes. Each shrimp was sweet and fresh, even under a cloak of seasoning on the shells we peeled off. They were very easy to peel and eat…then enjoy!

A plate of steamed clams and a man holding one and a fork in the other hand.
Basket of steamed peel and eat NC shrimp in the Outer Banks of NC.

Dinky’s, in Hatteras

One of the things you may have to deal with if you go to the Outer Banks during shoulder season, when temperatures get a little cooler (especially at night) is high winds and cold weather.

The night we went to Dinky’s was prime for indoor seating and comfort foods. And that’s exactly what we got at one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks.

Exterior of the Village Marina building where Dinky's restaurant is in the Outer Banks.

We couldn’t decide to eat here, or the neighboring Breakwater Restaurant. Both menus looked good and for all the positive or negative reviews at Breakwater Restaurant, there were equal pro/con thoughts on TripAdvisor for Dinky’s.

What sold us was looking at the daily specials on Dinky’s Facebook page that day. When we read, “Buffalo Tuna Bites with a Ranch Dipping Sauce $12” the decision was made! (Dan’s from Buffalo, NY – why wouldn’t we want more Buffalo sauce in our lives?)

Tuna bites covered in orange Buffalo sauce, dipped in ranch dressing.

We put our names down on the waiting list because they were seating at 50% capacity and it was peak dinner time on a Friday night. The 30 minutes flew by; we were soon seated inside their beautifully decorated restaurant.

I immediately noticed the gorgeous woodwork and asked if a boat builder had created the bar, railings and tables – the answer was yes. Little details like that do not go unnoticed with me!

Dinner at Dinky’s, One of the Best Seafood Restaurants in the Outer Banks

The seafood here was great. The tuna bites special did not disappoint – we’ve never had anything like it and we’d schedule a trip to the Outer Banks solely around when Dinky’s has this special again.

Dan had a parmesan crusted piece of Grouper based on the recommendation of the owners of Hatteras Saltworks, who we saw earlier that day and raved about the dish. He loved it!

I had an incredible piece of Yellow Fin Tuna, a special of the evening, with a Mediterranean twist. It was so big I unfortunately couldn’t finish it.

A plate of steamed vegetables and potatoes with parmesan crusted Grouper at Dinky's restaurant in Hatteras.
A plate of steamed vegetables and a Mediterranean sauce on top of a piece of fish.

Cafe Pamlico at the Inn on Pamlico Sound, in Buxton

We stayed at this delightful hotel for one beautiful evening. It was, by far, our favorite accommodations in the Outer Banks. A great perk was being able to walk from our room to dinner at one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks: Cafe Pamlico.

Blue skies above a yellow painted building at the Inn on Pamlico Sound in Buxton, in the Outer Banks of NC.

This is one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks that is more “upscale” than most place. The area is pretty casual and chill, overall. Beach vibes. But if you want to celebrate a birthday, anniversary or just get dressed up a little bit for dinner go to Cafe Pamlico.

We were excited to try a number of seafood options. We had their tasty crab bisque for an appetizer. Dan ordered their scallops entree served with angel hair pasta in a light cream sauce for his main course.

The scallops were huge and we couldn’t believe there were five of them. They were from Maine and weren’t local. Yet we appreciated how well they were cooked and how great the dishes tasted.

RELATED:  Top Spots to Indulge in Asheville's Brews and Art Views

Avenue Waterfront Grill, in Manteo

We arrived to Roanoke Island just in time for lunch. Avenue Waterfront Grille had a bit of a wait so we put our names down on the waitlist. It’s in the Manteo’s downtown area so we walked around the area while we waited for a table.

Front of the restaurant Avenue Waterfront Grill with a black awning, in Manteo in the Outer Banks.

We had lunch with a marina view. We could see the Elizabeth II 16th century vessel past the trees. (Trees that were helping block the October winds from our table, thankfully.)

The photo of the boat, below, is from a different angle in Manteo. But we had a great view of it from our outside table at Avenue.

We ordered a steamed shrimp appetizer to start because we were still dreaming of the shrimp we had at Pop’s the day before. The local NC steamed shrimp were delicious.

I ordered tacos with the grilled fish of the day. I loved that they had a bean salad option for a side – a healthy option! Dan ordered a fresh fish sandwich with French fries. (Men don’t take on calories like women do – am I right, ladies?)

Steamed peel and eat shrimp with seasoning on it, at Avenue Waterfront Grill, one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks.

One of the reasons this makes our list of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks is because of our waitress. The hostess was incredibly overwhelmed and all over the place. We forgave her for it. But what she lacked in organization and focus the waitress made up for in every way.

Not only was she phenomenal but she served with a smile every time she came outside to check on us. Which had to have been a bitter pill to swallow because she was wearing short sleeves and a small skirt in incredibly cold temperatures.

I don’t blame her for thinking it wouldn’t be so cold that day because it was the first week of October. But it was pretty darn cold that afternoon. She took it like a champ. Our dining experience here was far more superb because of her service.

Fish tacos and a bean salad at Avenue Waterfront Grill, one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks.
A fish sandwich and fries at one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks.

Single Fin Thai-Sushi Restaurant, in Nags Head

We guess the “single fin” in this restaurant’s name is a nod to surfboards or the single fin on Stand Up Paddle boards. Which, if it is, is super cute! What a great name for a sushi restaurant in the Outer Banks.

The takeout sushi we got here in Nags Head was great. (And I’m a tough sushi critic, always measuring things to sushi from trips to Japan even though it’s not apples to apples.) We picked it up on a rainy day after we visited the Wright Brothers National Monument just north of Single Fin in Kill Devil Hills.

We ordered three rolls (two regular – California and Spicy Tuna – and a “fancier” third roll) and two pieces of salmon nigiri. The fancy, priciest one was our least favorite of what we ordered. Next time we’ll stick to the great “regular” rolls we had and maybe even try some additional options.

We definitely recommend this as one of the best seafood restaurants in the Outer Banks if you’re craving sushi and maki.

A plate of takeout sushi from Single Fin Thai-Sushi restaurant in the Outer Banks.

Diamond Shoal’s Restaurant, in Hatteras

This is a restaurant and seafood market, in case you’re staying at a rental house with a kitchen and want to buy some fresh fish to cook.

They also have the only sushi bar on Hatteras Island, open for dinner from 5:00pm to 9:00pm Monday through Saturday. Sushi is not available on their lunch menu. That was okay though. We found other seafood options to enjoy.

(Single Fin Sushi is in Nags Head, which is the island north of Hatteras. Which is why Diamond Shoals Restaurant sushi bar remains the only sushi bar on Hatteras Island.)

Blue facade of a restaurant in Hatteras, called Diamond Shoals.

The Seafood Standouts at Diamond Shoals Restaurant: the Soups

We had to try a cup of their crab bisque and clam chowder after we learned the chowder is an award-winning family recipe.

RELATED:  Fascinating Bangkok Place to Visit: Bangrok Tour, East Meets West

They were good – I like soup to be hot but they were both served warm or room temperature, so it was skewing my opinion of them.

We appreciated the chunks of crab in one cup of seafood soup and the chunks of clams in the other. It definitely added to the flavor.

Two cups of soup, one orange and one white, on a plate with two spoons.

Lunch Entree Items on the Menu at Diamond Shoals

Most of the lunch menu at Diamond Shoals is dominated by fried seafood options, not grilled. We were told that even their “fresh bites” seafood appetizer is fried when we asked our waitress to clarify the menu description.

And what’s labeled “fresh” on their menu – including clam strips and oysters – is breaded and fried. Why would they fry everything if it’s fresh? We love some fried southern food, but seafood isn’t something we prefer prepared that way.

Half our lunch order defaulted to the only non-fried option I could find on their menu. Dan ordered the fried Grouper Lunch Basket and I ordered the Tropical Fish Wrap with grilled Grouper inside. Both were okay but we wouldn’t go back there again for a full meal.

If you visit Diamond Shoals Restaurant and want fish, we recommend getting a bowl of their clam chowder as your meal. Or trying some fresh catch as your entree – but it’ll be the priciest option.

Ask for your soup to be served very hot. (Better to ask for it to be served very hot and you can let it cool down for a minute, than for it to come out slightly warm and have it get cold way too fast.)

Wanchese Landing Grill & Marina, on Roanoke Island

We loved this adorable restaurant overlooking Wanchese marina. Candidly, it’s last on our list only because we didn’t end up getting seafood here. We only had time for breakfast one morning. (But it was delicious and we loved looking at all the enticing menu offerings – we’re dreaming of going back for their seafood.)

Colorful interior of a restaurant overlooking a marina in the Outer Banks, NC, at Wanchese Landing Grill & Marina on Roanoke Island.

Their reviews regarding their fish dishes, however (which we’ve thoroughly read because I swear reading restaurant reviews is a favorite past time of mine, are stellar.

They offer shrimp, clams, snow crab legs and oysters on their steam bar menu. Fresh catch is offered when in season that are posted on their daily menu board inside the grill.

They’re a quick serve/casual establishment where you order and pay at the counter in one area, then find a seat in their dining area. Your food is then delivered to your table.

We visited on a gloomy day in the Outer Banks but loved sitting inside the colorful dining area, watching the rainfall on the marina.

But if you visit and there’s warmer, sunnier weather they have an outside area to dine at as well. Though the view of the marina isn’t as good because it’s on their front lawn, on the opposite side of the water (closer to the street, where you enter the area).

Colorful interior of a restaurant with "Catch of the Day" written on the blackboard and a characterized fish next to it. Buoys are the left of the board at this best seafood restaurant in the Outer Banks.
Colorful interior of a restaurant overlooking a marina in the Outer Banks, NC, at Wanchese Landing Grill & Marina on Roanoke Island.
Please note: We thank the Tourism Authority for Dare County’s Outer Banks for generously hosting our tasting. We also may make a small commission from affiliate links in this post but all opinions are ours and we bring you genuine content with real facts, photos, thoughts and recommendations. Always.

For more Outer Banks content check out:

What type of seafood – fish, shellfish or mollusks – do you enjoy most?
Follow:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *